House Cakes

Our best-selling "House Cakes" ready for pick up right away.

We know you don't always have a chance to order well ahead of your special event but you need a great cake right away. Don't worry. We've got you covered!

What Our Customers Are Saying

"With a very short notice, Batter Up Bakery came through CLUTCH! I ordered their Tuxedo cake for our daughter's bday celebration and it was a HIT! Super MOIST and amazing chocolate mousse fill! Everyone who ate a slice all complimented how good the cake was! I will definitely be a returning customer. Thank you Batter Up!"

Ruthie V

Strawberry Shortcake

Best Seller!

Strawberry Shortcake

One of our best-sellers, this moist and delicious treat has fresh strawberries, creamy frosting, and tasty white cake.

$49.99

*includes taxes and shipping

Send me an order form
Tuxedo Cake

Tuxedo Cake

Having trouble choosing between chocolate or vanilla? Have them both in our delicious Tuxedo cake.

$49.99

*includes taxes and shipping

Mixed Fruit Cake

Mixed Berry Cake

Filled with berries, creamy frosting and layers of vanilla cake. Guaranteed to be a home run with your crowd!

$49.99

*includes taxes and shipping

Double Chocolate Cake

Double Chocolate Cake

Is it possible to be too chocolaty? We don't think so either. Chocolate cake, chocolate frosting, and chocolate syrup.

$49.99

*includes taxes and shipping

Carrot Cake

Carrot Cake

There is something magical about a well-made carrot cake and ours will not disappoint. Both sweet and moist, carrots, nuts and cream cheese icing

$49.99

*includes taxes and shipping

Funfetti Cake

Funfetti Cake

Always a favorite with the kids, this colorful and flavorful cake will go fast after you cut that first slice.

$49.99

*includes taxes and shipping

1. Call in your order

Call ahead and we will have it ready for you when you arrive.

2. Just show up

Drop by the shop and we will get it ready for you on the spot.

3. Have it delivered

We can bring your cake to you if needed. Delivery within 15 miles - $15.99

We have more options

Just let us know what you're looking for and give us a couple of days...